Wikia

GTA Wiki

Changes: GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion

Edit

Back to page

(Active requests: The course of this discussion has demonstrated that the community is not competent to handle this issue.)
 
(98 intermediate revisions by 16 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
:::'''<font color=red>There is currently a full set of Admins, so requests for promotion to Patroller only.</font>'''
 
 
 
Welcome to GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion.
 
Welcome to GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion.
   
Line 17: Line 15:
 
Editors with rollback and administrator experience on other wikis are encouraged to apply, and based on the editor in question exceptions may be made to the length of time editing required for promotion.
 
Editors with rollback and administrator experience on other wikis are encouraged to apply, and based on the editor in question exceptions may be made to the length of time editing required for promotion.
   
When applying for promotion, a ''community vote'' will take place. Voting lasts 7 days, although it may be allowed to run shorter (in the case of an obvious pass/fail) or longer (in the case of a very close vote) at sysop discretion.
+
When applying for promotion, a ''community vote'' will take place. Voting lasts 7 days, although it may be allowed to run shorter (in the case of an obvious pass/fail) or longer (in the case of a very close vote) at bureaucrat discretion. Only bureaucrats should close votes.
   
 
Application users who are caught tampering with other users votes, such as changing a no to a yes, will have their request closed immediately.
 
Application users who are caught tampering with other users votes, such as changing a no to a yes, will have their request closed immediately.
Line 27: Line 25:
 
*[[GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion/Archived Requests 2011-12]]
 
*[[GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion/Archived Requests 2011-12]]
 
*[[GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion/Archived Requests 2013]]
 
*[[GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion/Archived Requests 2013]]
  +
*[[GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion/Jan 2014 Administrator Election]]
   
 
==Active requests==
 
==Active requests==
  +
   
 
==Inactive requests==
 
==Inactive requests==
===Kingrhem - Patroller===
+
===Carl Johnson Jr. - Patroller===
   
::Closed 17:44, June 17, 2013 (UTC) as '''<font color=red>Unsuccessful</font>''' - <b>[[User:McJeff|Jeff]]</b> ([[User_talk:McJeff|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/McJeff|stalk]])
+
::Closed 22:32, February 9, 2014 (UTC) as '''<font color=green>Successful</font>'''
+
Hello, I'm Carl Johnson Jr! After doing more than 2,500 edits on this wiki, I've decided that it's time to rise up as a patroller. I tend to patrol this wiki several times throughout the day. When I first joined, I mostly made edits about grammar, punctuation, etc. When [[Grand Theft Auto V]] came out, I was shocked at how many articles were still not made/cleaned up. I was inspired by how well written the [[Liberty City (HD Universe)]] articles were written, so I modelled my style of writing towards them. I'm responsible for adding details and better descriptions in articles like [[Paleto Bay]], along with adding new images. I also made various articles like [[Puerto Del Sol]]. The random page button also helps me clean up the wiki overall, and also allows me to suggest to admins on changing some page names I find. I feel that I'm ready to make a jump to patroller. Thank you for taking your time to read this! [[User:Carl Johnson Jr.|Carl Johnson Jr.]] ([[User talk:Carl Johnson Jr.|talk]]) 17:35, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
Hi, My name is Kingrhem and I'm asking for Patroller rights to make this wiki clean from any errors . I have a hundred edits on this wiki, my grammar is very good and I have been a active for about month. I'm available for 10 hours a day. And I know a-lot about the GTA Series.[[User:Kingrhem|Kingrhem]] ([[User talk:Kingrhem|talk]]) 14:03, June 12, 2013 (UTC)
 
   
 
====Votes====
 
====Votes====
*'''No''' - <b>[[User:McJeff|Jeff]]</b> ([[User_talk:McJeff|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/McJeff|stalk]])
+
*'''Undecided''' - <span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black">[[User:Dodo8|Dodo8]]</span> [[User talk:Dodo8|<sup>''<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black>Talk</span>''</sup>]] 19:05, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*'''No '''- [[User:Mikey Klebbitz|Mikey Klebbitz]] ([[User talk:Mikey Klebbitz|talk]]) 21:04, June 12, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''Yes''' [[User:LS11sVaultBoy|LS11sVaultBoy]] ([[User talk:LS11sVaultBoy|Talk]]) 19:34, February 1, 2014 (UTC)\
*'''Absolutely Not''' - [[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 21:56, June 12, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''Yes'''- [[Image:AK-28-Sig.png|50px|link=User:AK-28|AK-28]] ([[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt1.png|30px|User talk:AK-28|Talk]] ★ [[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt2.png|30px|Special:Contributions/AK-28|Edits]]) 20:54, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*'''Not Qualified''' - [[User:Tony 1998|Mr. T., That&#39;s Me!]] ([[User talk:Tony 1998|talk]]) 00:02, June 13, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''Neutral''' - <b>[[User:McJeff|Jeff]]</b> ([[User_talk:McJeff|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/McJeff|stalk]]) 19:44, February 5, 2014 (UTC)
*'''No '''- [[User:Boomer8|Boomer8]] ([[User talk:Boomer8|talk]]) 05:49, June 13, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''Yes''' - [[User:Messi1983|Messi1983]] ([[User talk:Messi1983|talk]]) 20:54, February 5, 2014 (UTC)
====Discussion====
+
*'''Yes''' - --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] • ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|edits]])''' 19:01, February 6, 2014 (UTC)
*One month and 100 edits isn't enough to qualify someone for patroller on a high-activity wiki like this one. Three months and 500 edits maybe. <b>[[User:McJeff|Jeff]]</b> ([[User_talk:McJeff|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/McJeff|stalk]]) 14:18, June 12, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''Yes''' - <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 22:31, February 9, 2014 (UTC)
*I think you'd have more chances if you applied next month with at least 500 edits. I don't think you need three months as long as you edit frequently and make substantial edits (just adding categories won't get you far). - [[User:Mikey Klebbitz|Mikey Klebbitz]] ([[User talk:Mikey Klebbitz|talk]]) 21:08, June 12, 2013 (UTC)
 
*As below, with the request that also failed, you haven't been on here long enough. I agree with McJeff in that I don't think you're worthy for promotion until you've been on here for about three months. Also, your grammar doesn't appear to be quite as good as you say; even your request paragraph has a few errors that, if I saw them on an information page, I would cringe at and take time to correct. Try again later in the year. - [[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 22:01, June 12, 2013 (UTC)
 
*Around 250 to 400 edits are enough to meet Patroller prerequisites, but they need to be good quality edits, not just adding a letters to a word or commenting on blogs. Don't go AWOL after you read this and edit a lot and try to apply again because that will show that you just want the position without any reasons. Keep up the good edits and help. Try to apply again in a month or so. [[User:Tony 1998|Mr. T., That&#39;s Me!]] ([[User talk:Tony 1998|talk]]) 00:02, June 13, 2013 (UTC)
 
*If you get some more edits under your belt, improve your grammar, and reaply in a month or so, you'll have a chance of becoming a patroller on the GTA Wiki. [[User:Boomer8|Boomer8]] ([[User talk:Boomer8|talk]]) 05:49, June 13, 2013 (UTC)
 
   
===Instulent===
+
====Comments====
  +
*I think you would do well as a patroller. [[User:LS11sVaultBoy|LS11sVaultBoy]] ([[User talk:LS11sVaultBoy|Talk]]) 19:34, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  +
*You have a nice contributing history, so I gave you my vote. [[Image:AK-28-Sig.png|50px|link=User:AK-28|AK-28]] ([[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt1.png|30px|link=User talk:AK-28|Talk]] ★ [[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt2.png|30px|link=Special:Contributions/AK-28|Edits]]) 20:54, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  +
*I think you'd do a good job as a patroller. [[User:Messi1983|Messi1983]] ([[User talk:Messi1983|talk]]) 20:54, February 5, 2014 (UTC)
  +
*After thinking about it for a while, I can see that you follow our policies, you're civil and cooperative. So I don't see any problem in promoting you. --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] • ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|edits]])''' 19:01, February 6, 2014 (UTC)
   
::Closed, June 9, 2013 as '''<font color=red>Unsuccessful</font>''' - <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 08:58, June 9, 2013 (UTC)
+
===Smashbro8- Patroller===
  +
::Closed 17:00, February 5, 2014 (UTC) as '''<font color=red>Unsuccessful</font>''' - <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]]
  +
Hi I am Smashbro8! I am a common editor on this wiki and I would like to be a patroller on the wiki. I have been on this wiki from since June 2013/July 2013. I started off as a minor editor but I began to help out the wiki with other stuff, specifically stuff containing Grand Theft Auto V. I've also created pages on my own such as [[Horny's Burgers]], the [[Paleto Forest Sawmill]], [[Designer Slave]], [[Palomino Avenue]], and [[Rex's Diner]]. I would like to be a patroller because I enjoy this wiki. Also, the wiki is randomly attacked by vandals, uncivil users, etc. I constantly watch over the wiki 24/7, however I am hesitant about undoing edits, and warning users due to my lack of staff powers and I also am not sure when I am correct or wrong. I also think that there should a patroller to patrol the wiki during the early morning and late nights, since I see this time as the time for editors to make nonsense on the page. I do not go to public school, and I am homeschooled, giving me the time to do work and look over the wiki as often as possible. I am a very helpful editor and am also very close to many editors on the wiki, making it easy for us to work together on stuff. I am also a good admin, as seen on Wii Wiki and Driv3r Wiki from the "My Favorite Wikis" section of my user page, however, I'll leave that for another year. Let me know what you all think! Thanks! [[User:Smashbro8|Smashbro8]] ([[User talk:Smashbro8|talk]]) 21:48, January 26, 2014 (UTC)Smashbro8
   
Hello Ladies and Gentlemen, my name is Instulent and I would like to be promoted as a patroller on the GTA Wiki. I've been on this wiki for almost a month, have done 1,100+ edits and counting and not one day with out editing. I have reported a few people who have either trolled etc to admins and I get along well with almost everyone on this wiki. I am a positive person who will do anything to a help a wiki out. Thank you for your time. [[User:Instulent|Instulent]] ([[User talk:Instulent|talk]]) 17:58, May 31, 2013 (UTC)
 
 
====Votes====
 
====Votes====
*'''No''' - <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 07:41, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''No''' - Simply not qualified, considering that we decided we need to be much more selective about promoting people to patroller after a couple got promoted on "I edit a lot" without actually knowing the rules. You say "I am hesitant about undoing edits, and warning users due to my lack of staff powers and I also am not sure when I am correct or wrong" - If you don't know whether you're right or wrong you should be asking other editors and making posts on the article talk pages. I notice your images don't follow [[GTA Wiki:Image Policy]]. You also say there's heavy vandalism, but it's actually lighter than usual and hasn't been severe enough for anyone to bother bringing it to the attention of any of the bureaucrats.<br />This isn't a "never" vote. If you're interested in becoming a patroller, the bureaucrats are usually glad to help teach new users learn what they need to do to get promoted, and plenty of editors have failed their first request for promotion and been promoted later. However, speaking for myself I intend to be very careful about promoting underqualified users. <b>[[User:McJeff|Jeff]]</b> ([[User_talk:McJeff|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/McJeff|stalk]]) 22:17, January 26, 2014 (UTC)
*'''No''' ''(not now)'' - <span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black">[[User:Dodo8|Dodo8]]</span> [[User talk:Dodo8|<sup>''<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black>Talk</span>''</sup>]]
+
*'''<strike>Yes</strike> No - '''[[User:LS11sVaultBoy|LS11sVaultBoy]] ([[User talk:LS11sVaultBoy|Talk]]) 12:38, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
*'''Computer says no''' - [[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 09:40, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''<strike>Yes (with conditions)</strike> No''' --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|edits]])''' 22:17, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
*'''Not Yet '''- [[User:Mikey Klebbitz|Mikey Klebbitz]] ([[User talk:Mikey Klebbitz|talk]]) 10:39, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''No''' - <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 22:44, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
*'''No''' - [[User:Messi1983|Messi1983]] ([[User talk:Messi1983|talk]]) 23:08, June 2, 2013 (UTC)
+
*<strike>'''Yes'''</strike>  '''No'''- [[Image:AK-28-Sig.png|50px|link=User:AK-28|AK-28]] ([[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt1.png|30px|User talk:AK-28|Talk]] ★ [[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt2.png|30px|Special:Contributions/AK-28|Edits]]) 10:48, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*'''Maybe''' - [[User:Cloudkit01|Cloudkit01]] ([[User talk:Cloudkit01|talk]]) 00:21, June 3, 2013 (UTC)
+
*'''No''' - <span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black">[[User:Dodo8|Dodo8]]</span> [[User talk:Dodo8|<sup>''<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black>Talk</span>''</sup>]] 15:45, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*'''YES- [[User:Sasquatch101|Sasquatch101]] ([[User talk:Sasquatch101|talk]]) 02:21, June 3, 2013 (UTC)'''
 
*'''Recuse'''- [[User:Tony 1998|Mr. T., That&#39;s Me!]] ([[User talk:Tony 1998|talk]]) 04:00, June 3, 2013 (UTC)
 
*'''No''' - --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]]-[[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|Edits]])''' 19:41, June 6, 2013 (UTC)
 
*'''Yes''' - [[User:Boomer8|Boomer8]] ([[User talk:Boomer8|talk]]) 05:04, June 7, 2013 (UTC)
 
   
 
====Comments====
 
====Comments====
*I'm certain you'd make a very good patroller. But does the red text at the top of the page not hinder your chances somewhat? --[[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 09:37, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*@McJeff. I clearly understand where you are coming from. Somethings I have written wrong in my request. I will undo edits and there are many times me, Cloudkit01 and other users had to report users to The Tom. The wiki does be under attack sometimes by vandals and other types of uncivil users and I have made reports to The Tom about them several times. Also, I try my best to follow the Image Policy, which however, is rather confusing to me. Sorry! [[User:Smashbro8|Smashbro8]] ([[User talk:Smashbro8|talk]]) 22:21, January 26, 2014 (UTC)Smashbro8
  +
*I know that there may be many problems, but just look at Thomas0802, he wasn't perfect at first but he's gradually gotten better. [[User:LS11sVaultBoy|LS11sVaultBoy]] ([[User talk:LS11sVaultBoy|Talk]]) 12:38, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  +
*One thing that I noticed is how cooperatively and friendly you are. You helped us a lot since the release of GTA V. I can consider your edits very useful and meaningful, but I'll have to disagree with few aspects: Actually you don't need/should hesitate when undoing edits, because the matter is, as a patroller, hence the name, you're patrolling the Wiki. This means, you should know the difference between what's right and what's wrong, this can be clearly explained if you read all of our [[GTA Wiki:Policy|policies]]. And about the image policy, this is a serious subject and should be followed. Even if I control the edits and images, someone who has been around here for months should know this. So, before closing the comment, I'll need to be sure you're respecting the following subjects:
  +
  +
:::Our [[GTA Wiki:Image Policy|image policy]].
  +
:::Know how to intervene in a [[GTA Wiki:Disputes|dispute]].
  +
:::When and how to [[Help:Reverting|revert]].
  +
  +
If you're able to accomplish this, then I'm sure you're able to be a patroller. --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] • ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|edits]])''' 22:17, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
   
:*I forgot to remove that. Due to the inactivity of a patroller there is an available place. <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 07:41, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*Not yet. You don't know policies and Wikia in general well enough yet. I had a lot of issues with you initially, since then you've gotten a lot better - much more civil - but for me you're just not there yet. Maybe in the future. <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 22:44, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
   
::*OK, that's fine, ta. - [[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 09:50, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*@Thomas0802 and LS11sVaultBoy, if you think he needs to work on things, don't vote yes until he has proven his competence. You shouldn't vote yes because you think he can get better, he needs to get better before you vote yes. <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 22:44, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
   
*Almost a month is not long enough, you're doing a good job though. Keep it up and apply again in a two months or so. <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 07:41, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*Patricularly true. How many time do you think we should we give him to prove it and apply again? Oh, and by the way, Carl Johnson Jr. is going to apply right now. Both concurring simultaneously, so what now? --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] • ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|edits]])''' 23:38, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
   
*You're doing a great job, but you still have some things to learn. Try again in a month or so.<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black">[[User:Dodo8|Dodo8]]</span> [[User talk:Dodo8|<sup>''<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black>Talk</span>''</sup>]]
+
*Nobody is perfect, so I gave you my vote, however you need to read and understand the policies. Being a patroller is about keeping this wiki strong and safe community, not the amount of edits you made. [[Image:AK-28-Sig.png|50px|link=User:AK-28|AK-28]] ([[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt1.png|30px|User talk:AK-28|Talk]] [[Image:AK-28-Sig-pt2.png|30px|Special:Contributions/AK-28|Edits]]) 10:48, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*Sadly it's still a no. An employer wouldn't promote an employee just three weeks after starting so it's the same principle here. - [[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 09:43, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*@Thomas I'd say a month or two, just enough time for him to show us he is capable of being a good patroller. We do the same vote with Carl. <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 11:58, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*I agree. Some more weeks will give you more chances. Your work has been great, so far, but you need some more time to consolidate and run for patrollership again. If you wait 2-3 weeks, I might vote "'''Yes'''", the next time, Instu. [[User:Mikey Klebbitz|Mikey Klebbitz]] ([[User talk:Mikey Klebbitz|talk]]) 10:43, June 1, 2013 (UTC)
+
*@Smashbro, don't be disheartened by my vote, you're a good editor, you need to take the criticism on board - particularly Jeff's - and improve. You're still learning and you're doing the right thing by asking the staff plenty of questions. <font size="+1.5" face="Trajan Pro"><b>[[User:The Tom|Tom]]</b></font> [[User talk:The Tom|<sup><u>Talk</u></sup>]] 11:58, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*It is a good idea to wait on an editor who has just started out and may not be fully commited. However, in your case you seem to be very much into bettering the GTA Wiki. Your grammar and overall skills are what fit the patroller title; so I don't belive it's necessary to wait a month on a perfectly good editor. [[User:Sasquatch101|Sasquatch101]] ([[User talk:Sasquatch101|talk]]) 02:21, June 3, 2013 (UTC)
+
*OK The Tom, we shall do this in a month or so. I clearly understand the Image Policy now but I'm so confused on reverting multiple edits. [[User:Smashbro8|Smashbro8]] ([[User talk:Smashbro8|talk]]) 15:27, February 1, 2014 (UTC)Smashbro8
*He is a great editor, but I noticed some of his edits on info and images have fanon-like wordings. Despite I told him and Tom that a Patroller spot is open, I'm going to avoid voting because saying a no doesn't feel right to me nor does saying a "yes" because of his somewhat "fanon-phrases" on pages and image captions. {{unsigned|Tony 1998}}
+
*Most of your edits are good, you are civil, but I agree with the others, you should learn more about policies before becoming a patroller.<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black">[[User:Dodo8|Dodo8]]</span> [[User talk:Dodo8|<sup>''<span style="color:#FF6600; font-family:Cooper Black>Talk</span>''</sup>]] 15:45, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
*User has only been here a short time, hence why I have voted no for the time being. [[User:Messi1983|Messi1983]] ([[User talk:Messi1983|talk]]) 03:20, June 5, 2013 (UTC)
 
*However the number of edits doesn't matter, what matter to be a standard is how your edits are useful ( for example not adding a comma or something like this ) and remember, you did good edits and uploaded images in these times, your activity is too ok, but it's all about the time, wait a little and you can ask again. --'''[[User:Thomas0802|Thomas0802]] ([[User talk:Thomas0802|talk]]-[[Special:Contributions/Thomas0802|Edits]])''' 19:44, June 6, 2013 (UTC)
 
*The result and the reason behind it seems pretty unanimous. D'you reckon it might be worth getting rid of this and postponing the vote to a later date? Providing Instulent stays committed and keeps his editing up to scratch, I'm sure there'll be a few more yeses after a while. Just not now. -[[User:NikoBellicsBoss11|NikoBellicsBoss11]] ([[User talk:NikoBellicsBoss11|talk]]) 20:28, June 6, 2013 (UTC)
 
*You have a ton of edits, you're active, and you seem like a nice guy; everything a patroller should have. So I've voted"yes".  [[User:Boomer8|Boomer8]] ([[User talk:Boomer8|talk]]) 05:04, June 7, 2013 (UTC)
 

Latest revision as of 07:58, February 13, 2014

Welcome to GTA Wiki:Requests for Promotion.

You may apply for Rollback Rights or Administrator privileges on this noticeboard. To do so, you must meet the prerequisites, and then state what position you are looking for and why you think you need the rollback and/or administrator tools.

Requests for Oversight and Checkuser must be done at Wikia Central (and they'll probably be declined).

Rollback is a tool that allows users to quickly revert vandalism.

Administrators have the power to block and ban users, protect pages, move images, and delete pages and images, in addition to rollback.

To qualify for rollback rights, editors must have been active for two months with no rules violations. Rollbackers must receive a 60% 'yes' percentage to be promoted.

To qualify for administrator rights, editors must have been active for four months with no rules violations. Administrators must receive a 70% 'yes' percentage to be promoted. Those applying for adminship will likely be asked questions on how they deal with certain situations. This is to see if a user has the capabilities of being an administrator.

Editors with rollback and administrator experience on other wikis are encouraged to apply, and based on the editor in question exceptions may be made to the length of time editing required for promotion.

When applying for promotion, a community vote will take place. Voting lasts 7 days, although it may be allowed to run shorter (in the case of an obvious pass/fail) or longer (in the case of a very close vote) at bureaucrat discretion. Only bureaucrats should close votes.

Application users who are caught tampering with other users votes, such as changing a no to a yes, will have their request closed immediately.

Please submit your requests at the top of the "Active requests" page subsection.

Requests where the voting has finished can be found at

Active requestsEdit

Inactive requestsEdit

Carl Johnson Jr. - PatrollerEdit

Closed 22:32, February 9, 2014 (UTC) as Successful

Hello, I'm Carl Johnson Jr! After doing more than 2,500 edits on this wiki, I've decided that it's time to rise up as a patroller. I tend to patrol this wiki several times throughout the day. When I first joined, I mostly made edits about grammar, punctuation, etc. When Grand Theft Auto V came out, I was shocked at how many articles were still not made/cleaned up. I was inspired by how well written the Liberty City (HD Universe) articles were written, so I modelled my style of writing towards them. I'm responsible for adding details and better descriptions in articles like Paleto Bay, along with adding new images. I also made various articles like Puerto Del Sol. The random page button also helps me clean up the wiki overall, and also allows me to suggest to admins on changing some page names I find. I feel that I'm ready to make a jump to patroller. Thank you for taking your time to read this! Carl Johnson Jr. (talk) 17:35, February 1, 2014 (UTC)

VotesEdit

CommentsEdit

  • I think you would do well as a patroller. LS11sVaultBoy (Talk) 19:34, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  • You have a nice contributing history, so I gave you my vote. AK-28-Sig (AK-28-Sig-pt1AK-28-Sig-pt2) 20:54, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  • I think you'd do a good job as a patroller. Messi1983 (talk) 20:54, February 5, 2014 (UTC)
  • After thinking about it for a while, I can see that you follow our policies, you're civil and cooperative. So I don't see any problem in promoting you. --Thomas0802 • (talkedits) 19:01, February 6, 2014 (UTC)

Smashbro8- PatrollerEdit

Closed 17:00, February 5, 2014 (UTC) as Unsuccessful - Tom Talk

Hi I am Smashbro8! I am a common editor on this wiki and I would like to be a patroller on the wiki. I have been on this wiki from since June 2013/July 2013. I started off as a minor editor but I began to help out the wiki with other stuff, specifically stuff containing Grand Theft Auto V. I've also created pages on my own such as Horny's Burgers, the Paleto Forest SawmillDesigner SlavePalomino Avenue, and Rex's Diner. I would like to be a patroller because I enjoy this wiki. Also, the wiki is randomly attacked by vandals, uncivil users, etc. I constantly watch over the wiki 24/7, however I am hesitant about undoing edits, and warning users due to my lack of staff powers and I also am not sure when I am correct or wrong. I also think that there should a patroller to patrol the wiki during the early morning and late nights, since I see this time as the time for editors to make nonsense on the page. I do not go to public school, and I am homeschooled, giving me the time to do work and look over the wiki as often as possible. I am a very helpful editor and am also very close to many editors on the wiki, making it easy for us to work together on stuff. I am also a good admin, as seen on Wii Wiki and Driv3r Wiki from the "My Favorite Wikis" section of my user page, however, I'll leave that for another year. Let me know what you all think! Thanks! Smashbro8 (talk) 21:48, January 26, 2014 (UTC)Smashbro8

VotesEdit

  • No - Simply not qualified, considering that we decided we need to be much more selective about promoting people to patroller after a couple got promoted on "I edit a lot" without actually knowing the rules. You say "I am hesitant about undoing edits, and warning users due to my lack of staff powers and I also am not sure when I am correct or wrong" - If you don't know whether you're right or wrong you should be asking other editors and making posts on the article talk pages. I notice your images don't follow GTA Wiki:Image Policy. You also say there's heavy vandalism, but it's actually lighter than usual and hasn't been severe enough for anyone to bother bringing it to the attention of any of the bureaucrats.
    This isn't a "never" vote. If you're interested in becoming a patroller, the bureaucrats are usually glad to help teach new users learn what they need to do to get promoted, and plenty of editors have failed their first request for promotion and been promoted later. However, speaking for myself I intend to be very careful about promoting underqualified users. Jeff (talk|stalk) 22:17, January 26, 2014 (UTC)
  • Yes No - LS11sVaultBoy (Talk) 12:38, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • Yes (with conditions) No --Thomas0802 • (talkedits) 22:17, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • No - Tom Talk 22:44, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • Yes  No- AK-28-Sig (AK-28-Sig-pt1AK-28-Sig-pt2) 10:48, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  • No - Dodo8 Talk 15:45, February 1, 2014 (UTC)

CommentsEdit

  • @McJeff. I clearly understand where you are coming from. Somethings I have written wrong in my request. I will undo edits and there are many times me, Cloudkit01 and other users had to report users to The Tom. The wiki does be under attack sometimes by vandals and other types of uncivil users and I have made reports to The Tom about them several times. Also, I try my best to follow the Image Policy, which however, is rather confusing to me. Sorry! Smashbro8 (talk) 22:21, January 26, 2014 (UTC)Smashbro8
  • I know that there may be many problems, but just look at Thomas0802, he wasn't perfect at first but he's gradually gotten better. LS11sVaultBoy (Talk) 12:38, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • One thing that I noticed is how cooperatively and friendly you are. You helped us a lot since the release of GTA V. I can consider your edits very useful and meaningful, but I'll have to disagree with few aspects: Actually you don't need/should hesitate when undoing edits, because the matter is, as a patroller, hence the name, you're patrolling the Wiki. This means, you should know the difference between what's right and what's wrong, this can be clearly explained if you read all of our policies. And about the image policy, this is a serious subject and should be followed. Even if I control the edits and images, someone who has been around here for months should know this. So, before closing the comment, I'll need to be sure you're respecting the following subjects:
Our image policy.
Know how to intervene in a dispute.
When and how to revert.

If you're able to accomplish this, then I'm sure you're able to be a patroller. --Thomas0802 • (talkedits) 22:17, January 31, 2014 (UTC)

  • Not yet. You don't know policies and Wikia in general well enough yet. I had a lot of issues with you initially, since then you've gotten a lot better - much more civil - but for me you're just not there yet. Maybe in the future. Tom Talk 22:44, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • @Thomas0802 and LS11sVaultBoy, if you think he needs to work on things, don't vote yes until he has proven his competence. You shouldn't vote yes because you think he can get better, he needs to get better before you vote yes. Tom Talk 22:44, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • Patricularly true. How many time do you think we should we give him to prove it and apply again? Oh, and by the way, Carl Johnson Jr. is going to apply right now. Both concurring simultaneously, so what now? --Thomas0802 • (talkedits) 23:38, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
  • Nobody is perfect, so I gave you my vote, however you need to read and understand the policies. Being a patroller is about keeping this wiki strong and safe community, not the amount of edits you made. AK-28-Sig (AK-28-Sig-pt1AK-28-Sig-pt2) 10:48, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  • @Thomas I'd say a month or two, just enough time for him to show us he is capable of being a good patroller. We do the same vote with Carl. Tom Talk 11:58, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  • @Smashbro, don't be disheartened by my vote, you're a good editor, you need to take the criticism on board - particularly Jeff's - and improve. You're still learning and you're doing the right thing by asking the staff plenty of questions. Tom Talk 11:58, February 1, 2014 (UTC)
  • OK The Tom, we shall do this in a month or so. I clearly understand the Image Policy now but I'm so confused on reverting multiple edits. Smashbro8 (talk) 15:27, February 1, 2014 (UTC)Smashbro8
  • Most of your edits are good, you are civil, but I agree with the others, you should learn more about policies before becoming a patroller.Dodo8 Talk 15:45, February 1, 2014 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki